|
In the rush to generate a new battle in the
r&b wars (see: Stax vs. Motown, Prince vs. Michael Jackson, Alicia Keys vs. India
Arie), observers have pitted newcomers Ashanti and Tweet against each other. With
Ashanti's record-setting status as the first woman to begin her career with three top 10
singles (including her collaborations with Fat Joe and Ja Rule), early returns have her
winning the battle. But other than being proteges of famous crews
(Ashanti is down with Murder Inc., Tweet is a friend of Missy Elliott), legitimate
comparisons between the two are hard to find. In terms of emotional depth and
musicianship, these sisters are coming from different places.
Much like Craig David, Ashanti's music is aimed at the 21 and under
market, so don't expect a lot of variety here. As r&b newcomers tend to do,
Ashanti's primary subject matter is relationships. But the simplicity of the song titles -
"Foolish," "Dreams," "Happy" - reflects Ashanti's
inexperience in the game of love. Give Irv Gotti credit for masking Ashanti's
deficiencies with ear-pleasing production that emphasizes the hooks, one reason she's on
the radio every half-hour. Murder Inc.'s franchise player, Ja Rule, makes a couple
of appearances, but the real interest in the album comes from seeing Ashanti's emergence
as a songwriter. As she matures, she could develop into a talent deserving of her
hype.
By comparison, Southern Hummingbird announces the arrival of a
fully formed artist. Now 30 years old, Tweet draws upon her talents as a self-taught
guitarist and drummer in addition to her struggles with depression to give Hummingbird
a level of sincerity missing from most artists.
The first single "Oops (Oh My)" is one of the year's hottest
jams, but not an accurate portrayal of the album. Instead check for ballads like
"My Place" and "Motel," where Tweet's gentle but expressive voice
comes to the forefront. Tweet's amalgamation of Prince and classic soul marks her as
one of the most promising acts of the year.
Ashanti may well be the princess of r&b, but Tweet is more of a
natural woman.
Copyright ©2002 AllThingsDeep.com. All rights reserved. |
|
Released 2002 on Universal (click on cover to buy)Selected Tracks:
Foolish
Dreams
Voodoo
Released 2002 on Elektra (click on cover to buy)
Selected Tracks:
Beautiful
Drunk
My Place
|